Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
EFFECT OF PLASTIC MULCH IN VEGETABLES PRODUCTION
1. Introduction
1.1. Background Vegetables production is one of the emerging businesses in Nepal both
in on season and off season. But the yield of the vegetables is low as
compared to the other countries in Nepal. Although many efforts had
laid out for its improvement the desired level of the expectation
cannot be met till now. The total production of the vegetables in the
year 2066/67 was 275406 mt from the area 225154 ha with the
productivity of 12233 kg/ha. The contribution of the agriculture in
the total national GDP is 32.60% out of which the contribution of the
vegetables sector in national GDP is 9.7% (VDD, 2066/67). The income
is quite far better than any other crops i.e. 2-4 times more cash
than other crops. Efforts have been made to increase the
production per unit area. Vegetables have much importance as
economic, nutritional, medicinal, and industrial and also have
employment opportunities. It needs 1.5 times more labor than
other crops.
Since the beginning of civilization, the man had developed
technologies to increase the efficiency of food production. The
use of plastic mulch in commercial vegetable production is one of
these traditional techniques that have been used since 1950’s. A
favorable soil-water-plant relation is created by placing mulch
over the soil surface. The microclimate surrounding the plant and
soil is significantly affected by mulch i.e. the thermodynamic
environment, the moisture, the erosion, the physical soil
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 1
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
structure, the incidence of pests and diseases, crop growth and
yield. In order to maximize water use efficiency by the plant and
to improve the quality of produce, the use of mulch has become an
important cultural practice in many regions of the world for the
commercial production of vegetable crops.
Mulching is an agricultural cropping technique that involves
placing organic or synthetic materials on the soil around plants
to provide a more favorable environment for growth and
production. Organic mulches are being used traditionally by the
farmers. The most commonly used organic mulches in Nepal are:
rice straw, wheat straw, dried maize plant, sugarcane leaves,
grass clippings, etc.
The use of plastic mulch has brought a considerable change in
vegetable production in many countries. In temperate countries
the year round production of vegetables has been possible with
the use of plastic mulches. The growing period of crops with a
tropical origin have also been extended (Lamont, 1991). The
plastic mulch may be transparent, black, red, yellow or others
depending on the purpose of the mulch (Rudich, 1979).
1.2. Problem and RationaleLower productivity of vegetables in Nepal is due to excessive
rainfall, drought, weeds, pest and diseases, poor cultural
practices, leaching of the nutrients from the soil and low soil
fertility. The high night and day temperatures are the common
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 2
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
phenomenon in terai region that may be accounted for the reduced
flowering, fruit set and ultimately lower yield vegetables.
Mulching is one of the techniques which can help to reduce all
these problems and increase the crop yield. A favorable soil-
water-plant relation is created by placing mulch over the soil
surface. The microclimate surrounding the plant and soil is
significantly affected by mulch i.e. the thermodynamic
environment, the moisture, the erosion, the physical soil
structure, the incidence of pests and diseases, crop growth and
yield. In order to maximize water use efficiency by the plant and
to improve the quality of produce, the use of mulch has become an
important cultural practice for commercial production of
vegetable crops. This is one of the least cost methods to
increase vegetables production in Nepal which is helpful to the
small holder also.
Plant growth performance and yields of various vegetable crops
such as muskmelon (Battikhi and Ghawi, 1987; Bonanno and Lamont,
1987), water melon (Bhella, 1988a), tomato (Bhella, 1988b), red
pepper (Kwon, 1988) and eggplant (Carter and Johnson, 1988) can
be significantly improved by mulching.
Mulches reduce weed growth by making conditions unfavorable for
germination of weed seeds and by providing physical barrier for
emerging weeds. A good mulch layer can save many hours of
laborious weeding. Fumigants like methyl bromide can be used
effectively under plastic mulch to provide successful season long
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 3
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
control not only over weeds but also on fungal and bacterial
diseases and plant parasitic nematodes (Noling and Becker, 1994).
Mulches are very useful for maintaining uniform moisture
condition of the soil. Water loss through evaporation is
decreased, and soil erosion is decreased as the impact of heavy
rainfall is reduced by the layer of mulch. Mulch also reduces
splacing of soil onto the fruits, leaves and other parts of the
plant. This keeps the product cleaner and helps prevent the
spread of disease (Lamont, 1991).
Black plastic mulch can accelerate crop production by as much as
one to two weeks. Clear plastic mulch has shown to increase
earliness by as much as three weeks in cool climates. Weed
growth, however, can be a major problem under clear plastic
unless appropriate herbicides or fumigants are used (Lamont
1991).
Plastic mulch is nearly practically impervious to carbon dioxide,
a gas that is of prime importance in photosynthesis. Research has
shown that very high levels of CO2 may build up under the
plastic, because the film does not allow it to escape. It has to
come through the holes punched in the plastic for the plants and
a “chimney effect” is created, resulting in localized
concentrations of abundant CO2 for the actively growing leaves
(Lamont, 1991).
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 4
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Mulches also help in reducing the fertilizer losses. Flood and
furrow irrigation techniques tend to leach nitrogen and other
water soluble nutrients below the root zone. Since plastic mulch
techniques generally include drip irrigation, nutrient loss is
kept to a minimum. Nutrients can be injected into the drip system
and accurately delivered to the root zone. Organic mulches add
nutrients to the soil as they decompose, improving its tilth and
moisture holding capacity (Lamont 1991).
Mulches have been found to be useful for the control of insects.
Use of reflective silver and white plastic mulches to delay onset
of aphid vectored viruses in summer squash has been well
documented in the research literature (Conway et al. 1989; Lamont et
at. 1990). As yellow color is known to attract insects, yellow
color plastic can be used to control insect with insecticide
spray over the mulch (Lamont 1991).
Mulch also helps reduce the disease incidence. Mulch application
increased microbial activity and biomass in soil (Manna et al.
2001) and reduced the severity of some above ground diseases of
plants in crops such as tomatoes (Abbasi et al. 2002).
1.3. Objectives
To identify the effect of different (organic and inorganic)
mulch in vegetables production.
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 5
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
2. Literature Review
2.1 Effects of mulching on soil environment
2.1.1 Effects on soil temperature
Soil temperature is modified by mulches to various degrees.
Plastic mulches warm the soil more quickly, increasing early
plant development in the cooler months. However, under high
temperature conditions during the summer, plastic may warm the
soil to temperatures that might be deleterious to plant growth.
Organic mulches act as insulation, helping keep soil cooler and,
therefore, should be applied in the hot seasons (Relf and
McDaniel, 2004).
Several reports showed that mulch application can modify the soil
temperature. Organic mulch as well as reflective plastic mulch
helps reduce the soil temperature while the clear and black
plastic mulch increases the soil temperature. Organic mulches
reduce the soil temperature by protecting the soil from direct
heat of the Sun. Dhesi et al. (1964) and Sing et al. (1966) observed
reduced soil temperature with the use of organic mulches in
potato.
Schalk and Robbins (1987) found aluminum mulches (aluminum and
aluminized plastic films) lowered soil temperatures and reduced
heat stress for young tomato Seedlings increasing their survival
in the fall season.
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 6
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Tu et al. (1991) studied the effectiveness of clear plastic mulch
for the control of southern blight disease of tomato and found
that temperature under soil surface 5cm in depth could be
increased by 12°C after mulching and soil temperature could be
reached at or over 40°C after 119 hours, while the soil
temperature of control plot without mulching never reached 40°C.
The highest and the lowest temperature of soil were 51°C and 27°C
for the plot with mulching treatment, and were 39°C and 23°C for
the control plot without mulching treatment, respectively.
Teasdale and Abdul-Baki (1995) found increased soil temperature
under black polythene mulch which probably accounted for greater
early root and shoot growth and greater early yield of tomatoes
grown with black polyethylene than hairy vetch residue or bare
soil.
Hooda et al. (1999) also found that mulch with black polyethylene
recorded significantly higher soil temperature compared to other
mulch materials and the control (no mulch). Similarly the study
carried out by Diaz-Pérez and Dean Batal (2002) showed that daily
mean values of root zone temperature (RZT) under plastic mulches
were higher (1 to 5°C) than those of air temperature. The highest
RZT at mid day occurred under black mulch, and the lowest under
bare soil and white mulch. Bare soil showed the largest diurnal
RZT fluctuation.
A study was conducted by Gough (2001) to find out the effect of
color of plastic mulch on root development of pepper and found
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 7
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
highest mean soil surface temperature under red polyethylene
mulch and lowest on the bare soil. Temperature 5 cm beneath the
surface of all treatments was 7°C lower than at the surface, with
the greatest difference occurring beneath the red mulch and the
least beneath the silver. Red plastic mulch had the highest
subsurface soil temperature while bare soil and silver mulch had
the lowest. Averaging the surface and subsurface mean
temperatures, the red mulch provided the warmest and the silver
the coolest soil environment, bare soil and black mulch being the
intermediate.
The soil temperature under a plastic mulch depends on the thermal
properties (reflectivity, absorbitivity, or transmittancy) of a
particular material in relation to incoming solar radiation.
Black plastic mulch, the pre dominate color used in vegetable
production is an opaque blackbody absorber and radiator. Black
mulch absorbs most ultra-violet (UV), visible, and infrared
wavelengths (IR) of incoming solar radiation and re-radiates
absorbed energy in the form of thermal radiation or long-
wavelength infrared radiation. Much of the solar energy absorbed
by black plastic mulch is lost to the atmosphere through
radiation and forced convection. The efficiency with which black
mulch increases soil temperature can be improved by optimizing
conditions for transferring heat from the mulch to the soil.
Because thermal conductivity of the soil is high relative to that
of air, much of the energy absorbed by black plastic can be
transferred to the soil by conduction if contact is good between
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 8
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
the plastic mulch and the soil surface. Soil temperatures under
black plastic mulch during the daytime are generally 5° F higher
at a 2-inch depth and 3° F higher at a 4-inch depth compared to
those that of bare soil. Locher et al. (2005) revealed that use of
dark colored mulch is the safest solution because even in case of
high air temperature and solar radiation, the soil does not warm
to a harmful degree.
In contrast, clear plastic mulch absorbs little solar radiation
but transmits 85% to 95%, with relative transmission depending on
the thickness and degree of opacity of the polyethylene. The
under surface of clear plastic mulch usually is covered with
condensed water droplets. This water is transparent to incoming
shortwave radiation but is opaque to outgoing long wave infrared
radiation; so much of the heat lost to the atmosphere from a bare
soil by infrared radiation is retained by clear plastic mulch.
Thus, daytime soil temperatures under clear plastic mulch are
generally 8 to 14° F higher at a 2-inch depth and 6 to 9° F
higher at a 4-inch depth compared to those of bare soil. Clear
plastic mulches generally are used in the cooler regions. Using
clear plastic mulch will require the use of an herbicide, soil
fumigant, or solarization to control weeds
white-on-black or silver reflecting mulches can result in a
slight decrease in soil temperature -2° F at 1-inch depth or -
0.7° F at a 4-inch depth compared to bare soil, because they
reflect back into the plant canopy most of the incoming solar
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 9
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
radiation. These mulches can be used to establish a crop when
soil temperatures are high and any reduction in soil temperatures
is beneficial. Depending on the degree of opacity of the white
mulch, it may require the use of a fumigant or herbicide because
of the potential weed growth.
Clear plastic is believed to achieve higher soil temperatures
than black plastic. This happens because much of the incident
radiation is absorbed by colored films (Argall and Stewart, 1990)
and does not pass through to the soil. Results indicated that
clear plastic heated soil less than black plastic, if it was
placed tightly across the soil with good contact between the soil
surface and the mulch. They also suggested that if clear plastic
mulches placed loosely over the soil an insulating air layer
develops which results in the soil heat storage and reducing heat
loss.
2.1.2 Effects on soil moisture
Water is essential for growth and development. It is also a major
cost in agricultural systems. The success of many agricultural
forms relies on conservative and efficient use of water. Moisture
retention is undoubtedly the most common reason for which mulch
is applied to soil. Mulch is used to protect the soil from direct
exposure to the sun which would evaporate moisture from the soil
surface and cause drying of the soil profile. The protective
interface established by the mulch stops raindrop splash by
absorbing the impact energy of the rain, hence reducing soil
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 10
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
surface crust formation. The mulch also slows soil surface runoff
allowing a longer infiltration time. These features result in
improved water infiltration rates and higher soil moisture. An
auxiliary benefit of mulch reducing soil splash is the decreased
need for additional cleaning prior to processing of the herb
foliage (Barker, 1990). Organic and inorganic mulches have been
shown to improve the moisture retention of soil. This extended
water holding ability enables plants to survive during low
rainfall periods. The use of plastic mulch can be improved if
under-mulch irrigation is used in combination with soil moisture
monitoring. The influence of rainfall events are not as great
when plastic mulch is used, necessitating active irrigation
management. Under mulch, irrigation of vegetable crops has been
shown to improve crop yields more than overhead irrigation
systems (Clough et al., 1990). Mulch enables the soil moisture
levels to maintain for longer periods. In some cases while
providing improved moisture conditions within the soil, the mulch
changes the plants microclimate so that it uses more water (Clark
and Moore, 1991 and Zajicek and Heilman, 1991), thus negating the
initial benefit. Plastic mulch conserved 47.08% of water and
increased yield by 47.67% in tomato when compared to un-mulched
control (Friake et al., 1990). Palada et al. (2003) concluded that
plastic mulching resulted in 33 to 52% more efficient use of
irrigation water in bell pepper compared to bare soil.
Soil moisture levels are usually higher under mulched than
unmulched soil because the mulch acts as a vapor barrier which
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 11
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
reduces evaporation. The effectiveness of polyethylene coated
paper mulches in altering soil environment was investigated by
Liptay and Tiessen (1970). They found that polyethylene coated
paper mulches were as effective in reducing soil moisture
evaporation as the polyethylene mulches. But non- coated paper
mulches were not as effective as the coated mulches. Evaporation
from the bare soil was greater than from all the mulched plots;
however, irrigated, bare soils reach 100% of available water much
sooner than mulched soils.
Shrivastava et al. (1984) found that the organic mulches
effectively conserve the soil moisture in summer tomato
cultivation. They found the frequency of irrigation was reduced
by 55.5% by the mulch application without any adverse effect on
yield.
2.1.3 Effects on soil structure
Soil compactness is generally less under mulch than in bare soil.
Water from rain or irrigation falling directly on the soil tends
to compact the surface of the soil thus reducing soil aeration.
Specific mulches spread the impact of the water droplets over a
large surface area and reduce soil compaction (Liptay and
Tiessen, 1970). McIntyre et al. (2000) found lower soil bulk
density in the mulched treatments than in bare soil treatments in
0 to 0.5 meter depth. However below 0.5 meter depth there were no
significant differences between the mulched and bare soil
treatments. But Famoso and Bautista (1983) reported increased
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 12
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
bulk density of the soil with the use of sugarcane bagasse as
mulch in tomato. As reported by Tindall et al. (1991), straw mulch
resulted significantly greater infiltration rate, and lower pH,
bulk density, surface evaporation, cone index, soil temperature
and matrix potential than the plastic mulch.
2.2 Effects on nutrient level
Mulches also help in reducing the fertilizer losses. Flood and
furrow irrigation techniques tend to leach nitrogen and other
water soluble nutrients below the root zone. Since plastic mulch
techniques generally include drip irrigation, nutrient loss is
kept to a minimum. Nutrients can be injected into the drip system
and accurately delivered to the root zone (Lamont, 1991).
Liptay and Tiessen (1970) found that nitrate-N level of the soils
under mulches were higher than in the bare soils. But no
significant difference was observed between different mulch
treatments.
Famoso and Bautista (1983) found that mulching tomato with
sugarcane bagasse left to decompose for 8 months after milling
increased phosphorous and potash as well as organic matter
content of the soil.
Chilli plants grown on plastic mulch had significantly higher N
and K contents in leaf tissues at early fruiting stage when
compared with bare soil (Hassan et al., 1995).
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 13
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
A 3-year experiment was conducted to determine the optimum
fertilizer N requirements of fresh-market tomato grown on a hairy
vetch (Vicia villosa Roth.) or black polyethylene mulch. Tomatoes
grown under black polyethylene mulch required N at the rate of
130 to 144 kg/ha to achieve yields equivalent to those grown
following unfertilized hairy vetch (Abdul-Baki et al. 1997).
McIntyre et al. (2000) conducted a study to determine the effect of
mulching on above-and below ground biomass, soil and foliar
nutrient level and soil water uptake in banana. They found soil
organic C, P, and exchangeable K and Mg were significantly higher
in the mulched treatments than in bare soil.
2.3 Effects of mulching on weed growth
Weed control in crops is a difficult, time consuming and
expensive task. Plastic mulches have the potential to alter soil
temperature, crop water use, improve crop quality and in some
cases reduce weed competition, thereby improving crop development
and increasing yields (Lamont, 2005 and Ngouaajio and Ernest,
2005). Black plastic mulch is both effective at warming the soil
and reducing weed competition. Clear plastic mulch provides
greater soil warming, but it does not reduce the weed competition
(Lamont, 2005). Dark colored mulches lie across the soil and
around the crop reduce the amount of light reaching the soil and
thus inhibit weed germination and smother emerging weeds.
Mulching for weed control can take a number of forms: inorganic
or organic mulches can be applied and left in situ to control the
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 14
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
weeds; living mulches can be grown to choke out weeds before
planting the mulches are either killed with chemicals or complete
their life cycle before the growing season of the herb.
Solarisation uses an inorganic mulch and solar energy to
disinfect the soil, the mulch being removed prior to planting.
Similarly 100% weed control was observed in cassava peel with
black plastic mulch as compared to bare soil (Aniekwe et al.,
2004).
Weeds in tomato pose a serious problem and effect the crop
resulting about 57.6 percent reduction in yield (Singh and Singh,
1992). The demand for integrated weed management approaches has
resulted from increasing energy, labor and material costs
associated with weed control practices in conventional cropping
systems. Degraded herbicide compounds have also been detected in
surface and ground waters (Kolpin et al. 1997), generating an
interest in alternative strategies.
Economically and environmentally sustainable weed control
alternatives, such as non-synthetic or natural mulches can
provide many benefits, including weed suppression and delayed
weed emergence (Teasdale and Mohler, 1993). Increasing interest
in more biologically based cropping alternatives and pressure to
reduce the use of herbicides has led researchers to test organic
mulches for their ability to reduce weeds (Creamer et al. 1996;
Teasdale and Abdul-Baki, 1998). Among the organic mulches, winter
annual legume hairy vetch (Vicia villosa R.) not only increased tomato
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 15
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
yield relative to plastic mulch but also reduces weed emergence
and water loss (AbdulBaki, and Teasdale, 1993).
Shrivastava et al. (1994) have recommended use of drip irrigation
along with plastic mulch in the areas of high weed intensity.
This treatment resulted in 95% reduction in weed infestation,
53% higher yield and 44% saving in irrigation water when compared
with the surface flood without mulch treatment.
Sudha et al. (1998) conducted field studies on soil solarization
for weed control in tomatoes and tobacco nursery beds and found
the lowest weed count and weed dry matter in soil solarization
with transparent polyethylene followed by soil solarization with
black polyethylene.
Some species of Brassica family when used as mulch caused temporary
weed suppression which is probably due to secondary plant
metabolites (Al-Khatib et a!.. 1997). Brassica spp. contain high
amount of glucosinolates. These secondary plant metabolites play
a key role for weed suppression as they can be converted to the
corresponding isothiocyanates by the plant enzyme myrosinase and
these isothiocyanates are phytotoxic (Fenwick et al., 1983). Living
plants do not actively release high amounts but during
decomposition of dead plant material or by incorporating green
plant material into the soil, larger amounts of isothiocyanates
can be released (Petersen et al., 2001). If Brassica spp. plant
tissues are incorporated into the soil, it is possible to control
weeds in the following crop by isothiocyanates released from the
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 16
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
mulch (AI-Khatib et al., 1997). This might be a chance to reduce
the use of herbicides and could be an additional tool to control
herbicide-resistant weeds.
The phytotoxic properties of some other plants as cover crop and
mulch were also studied by others. And in some cases this
property makes a disadvantage to the tomato crop. A 5-yrs field
experiment conducted by Caamal-Maldonado et al. (2001) evaluated
the effect of four legumes, velvet bean (Mucuna deeringiana Merr.)
and jackbean (Canavalia ens forinis L.) used as living cover crops, and
jumbiebean (Leucaefla leucocephala L.) and wild tamarind (Lysiloma
tatisiliquum L.) used as dead mulches incorporated on soil surface,
on weed growth and corn yield. The number, biomass, diversity,
and relative importance of weeds, as well as corn yield were
evaluated. All legumes reduced weed growth with velvet bean (as
living cover crop) producing the largest weed biomass reduction
(68%). They also conducted in-vitro bioassay and greenhouse
experiment to evaluate the toxic effect of above four legumes.
The aqueous leachates of all four legumes exhibited strong
photoxic effect the radicle growth of the all three test plants
viz, barnyard grass (Echinochloa crusgalli L.), amaranth (Amaranthus
hypochondiacus L.) and tomato. Velvetbean and jackbean caused the
highest inhibition on amaranth radicle growth. Tomato was
strongly inhibited by jackbean and by other treatments an
indication that the use of these legumes as mulches in tomato
crop should be avoided (Caamal-maldonado et al., 2001).
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 17
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Masiunas et al (2003) conducted a study to determine the effect of
foam mulch and its color on weed control and on yields of basil
and tomatoes. The foam mulch controlled weeds comparable to black
plastic mulch. However the color of foam mulch did not affect
weed control because it did not allow light penetration and
served as a physical barrier impeding weed emergence.
2.4 Effects of mulching on vegetative characters
2.4.1 Effects on seedling and plant growth
Organic or inorganic soil mulches influence the crop in a number
of ways. Plastic mulches can offer a barrier against weeds,
moisture loss, nutrient loss, erosion, insect and disease injury
while encouraging plant establishment and an earlier crop of
potentially higher quality (Mugalla et al., 1996). The combined
effects of soil temperature, soil moisture and weed suppression
not only work to improve crop growth but they also facilitate
hand picking and lead to higher yield and increased fruit size
(Scheerens and Brenneman, 1994).
Mulching with black or clear plastic increased total plant growth
and led to an increased rate of branching and early flowering in
tomato (Wein and Minotti, 1988). Hassan et al. (1995) reported that
mulching is practically beneficial in chilli production. They
concluded that increased plant growth for mulched plants may be
related to soil moisture content because plant dry weight was
positively correlated with soil temperature and moisture content.
Hallidri (2001) stated that plant height and number of leaves
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 18
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
were higher in black and transparent polythene mulch than control
(bare soil) while no significant difference was observed in case
of stem diameter in cucumber.
Karp et al. (2006) reported that mulching treatment significantly
influenced nutrient content of leaves and chlorophyll contents
(381 SPAD units) were significantly lower in control plants
compared with plants grown on different mulches (498 and 542 SPAD
units). Plastic mulches increased crop growth (3.2–4.0 cm), dry
root mass (12.2–50.1%), nitrogen fixing activity (3.3–12.8%),
leaf chlorophyll content (41–78%) more reproductive buds (63.3–
94.1%) and starts flowering 9 days earlier in groundnut than un-
mulched control (Hu et al., 1995).
Vandenberg and Tiessen (1972) found growth of direct seeded
tomato plant was accelerated by both wax and polyethylene coating
on paper mulches. Albregts and Howard (1973) also found
germination of okra and early growth of okra and pepper were
greatest in the full mulch beds. Strip mulching increased the
early plant growth of pepper, but by midseason the advantage over
the unmulched treatment was no longer significant.
Mulching significantly increased vegetative growth, yield and
yield components of the tomato plants (Olasantan, 1985). Mulched
plants grew taller and had more branches than unmulched controls.
Schalk and Robbins (1987) observed increased plant height in
tomatoes with the application of aluminum mulches (aluminum and
aluminized plastic films).
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 19
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Wien and Minotti (1987) observed that total plant growth, as
measured by vine weights at final harvest, was increased by
plastic mulching. But in an experiment conducted by Gunadi and
Suwandi (1987), mulching did not significantly affect the growth
components. However, there was a tendency for the yield
components to increase by the application of straw mulch.
Ann and Ankara (2001) found that mulch application significantly
influenced plant height in tomato. They observed highest plant
height in tomato with straw mulch. Straw and transparent
polyethylene mulches recorded higher stem diameter than other
treatments.
Plastic mulches increased crop growth (3.2–4.0 cm), dry root mass
(12.2–50.1%), nitrogen fixing activity (3.3–12.8%), leaf
chlorophyll content (41–78%) more reproductive buds (63.3–94.1%)
and starts flowering 9 days earlier in groundnut than un-mulched
control (Hu et al., 1995).
The effect of plastic mulch and its color improve soil structure,
crop growth and its development. Growth, yield and nutrient
uptake are affected by plastic mulch and initial nitrogen levels
in the soil (Wein and Minotti, 1988).
The number of leaves per plant or dry weight per plant better
explains the changes in watermelon yield than net photosynthesis
rate (Ibarra-Jimenez et al., 2005). Similarly plant height, number
and length of main roots, fresh and dry weights of roots as well
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 20
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
as number of flower were significantly higher in plants grown on
mulch as compared to bare soil (Hasan et al., 2005). Leaf area
ratio and leaf weight ratio were not significantly different in
melon grown under plastic mulch but 10-20% higher than those on
the bare soil (control) (Lopez et al., 2000).
2.4.2 Effects on root growth and distribution
Little work has been done to describe the influence of mulch on
the root growth and distribution of vegetable crops. Wein (1997)
speculated that root growth and distribution was significantly
influenced by soil structure and management, including
cultivation, irrigation and the use of polyethylene mulch in
pepper. Gough (2001) reported that pepper plants grown under
silver mulch produced greatest number of lateral roots followed
by bare soil and black mulch, and the fewest roots under red
mulch. Color mulches influenced the total number of adventitious
and lateral roots but not the root system architecture of pepper
plant. Plants grown under mulch had fewer but thicker
adventitious roots. Wein et al. (1993) reported that tomato roots
were significantly longer 1 week after transplanting on plants
grown under clear polyethylene than on these grown without mulch.
Gupta and Acharya (1993) observed increased root mass under black
polyethylene mulch was attributed to the resultant increase in
soil temperature and nutrient uptake.
Kirnak and Demirtas (2006) both root and shoot dry weights of
cucumber plants were significantly improved by plastic mulch.
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 21
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Similarly plant height, number and length of main roots, fresh
and dry weights of roots as well as number of flower were
significantly higher in plants grown on mulch as compared to bare
soil (Hasan et al., 2005).
2.5 Effects of mulching on flowering and fruit setting
The effects of mulching on flowering and fruit setting were
studied by Vandenberg and Tissen (1972). The wax and polyethylene
coated paper mulch increased number of flower clusters, flowers
and fruit per plant. However, the response was higher in
polyethylene coated paper than in wax coated paper. Earlier
flowering was also observed in mulched plots relative to bare
plots. Famoso and Bautista (1983) observed increase in total
number of flower per plant when tomato was mulched with
sugarcafle bagasse.
Mulches ameliorated soil hydrothermal regime, improved vegetative
growth, advanced flowering and fruit yield of tomato plants when
compared with bare soil (Agele et al., 2000).
2.6 Effects of mulching on earliness
Wien and Minotti (1987) found plastic mulching led to early
flowering in tomato. West and Peirce (1988) observed black
polyethylene mulch and polyester row cover causes earliness
contributing to an increment in early eld. Wien and Minotti
(l988a) reported plastic mulch increased early flower number,
hastened flower production, and increased early yield in tomato.
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 22
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Hastening of maturity of plants on mulch resulted in a 22%
increase in ripe fruit and a decrease in percent green fruit at
final harvest. Peirce and (1989) also reported earliness in
flowering and ripening in tomato with black polyethylene mulch.
Though plastic mulch can help earliness organic mulch tends to
delay maturity. Rarnalan and Nwokeocha (2000) found rice straw
mulch significantly delayed the attainment of 50% fruiting by 6
days compared to the un-mulched plots. Similarly Ann and Ankara
(2001) also recorded shortest time for harvest in transparent and
black polythene mulch though the total yield was highest in wheat
straw mulched plots.
Vegetable crops grown under plastic mulches have shown earlier 7
to14 days and increased yields 2 to 3 times over vegetable crops
grown on bare soil (Lamont, 1993). Black plastic mulch doubled
the yield of tomatoes as well as increasing the amount of early
production for some cultivars when compared with un-mulched
control (Abdul- Baki et al., 1992).
2.7 Effects on total yield
Shrivastava et al. (1984) reported that the use of organic mulch in
tomato increased the yield and Kans grass (Saccarum spontaneum) as
mulch was found most effective giving 40 percent higher yield
than soil cultivation. Patil et al. (1973) and Sukia and Prabhakar
(1988) also obtained increased yield of tomato with polythene
mulching. Gunadi and Suwandi (1987) observed that the application
of straw mulch increased 15% of total yield and 16.3% of
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 23
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
marketable yield compared to no mulching. Similar observations
were made by Gupta and Gupta (1987) where straw mulching (6 T/ha)
together with light and frequent irrigation (30 mm water at E0=30
mm) to a sandy loam soil increased tomato yield up to 100%. Mulch
treatments improved the yields of tomato and the greatest yield
of large and extra-large fruits were obtained from plants grown
with aluminum alone, with aluminum laid over black plastic and
with black plastic alone (Schalk and Robbins, 1987). Ariyarathne
(1989) also reported mulching in tomato increased the marketable
and the total fruit yields as well as the number of marketable
fruit significantly.
Shrivastava et al., (1994) Conducted experiments from 1989 to 1991
to study the effect of drip, mulches (black plastic and Sugarcane
trash) and irrigation levels on tomato yield. This study revealed
that drip plus sugarcane trash mulch was the best combination,
which gave the highest fruit yield of about 51 metric Tons/ha
with 44% water saving.
A field trial conducted at AVRDC during the autumn season
revealed that yield of non-staked tomato was increased by 67.5%
when the crop was mulched with black plastic and by 15% when it
was mulched with rice straw. The high yield of plastic mulch
treatment was in terms of a high number of fruits per plant
(Sajjapongse et al., 1989). Hooda et al. (1999) also found highest
yield attributes in the black polyethylene mulch.
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 24
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Field experiments were conducted in Assam, India to evaluate the
effectiveness of different organic mulches including black
polyethylene sheet on tomato and okra by Sannigrahi and Borah
(2002). The mulch treatments were black polyethylene sheet, rice
straw, spent straw, water hyacinth (Eichhomia crassipes), thatch
grass (Imperata cylindrica), and no mulch (control). Mulching
increased the number of tomato fruits per plant and had higher
crop yield than the control. Water hyacinth mulch gave the
highest increase in tomato yield (by 91%).
Wien and Minotti (1987) conducted two field experiments with and
without plastic mulch in 1982 and 1983. Effects of the plastic
mulch dominated both experiments. Mulching increased early yield
only in 1983, but increased total yields by 13% and 79% in 1982
and 1983, respectively. Similarly in another experiment Wien and
Minotti (1988b) recorded 25% increase in yields of the first four
harvests in tomatoes with clear plastic mulch.
Bogle et al. (1989) compared performance of different plastic
mulches for three consecutive growing seasons. Use of black
plastic mulch resulted in 31% and 16% greater marketable tomato
yield in spring 1983 and 1984, than similar bare-soil (unmulched)
treatments, respectively. In fall 1983, use of white/black
(top/bottom) laminated plastic mulch reduced yields by 12%
compared to similar unmulched treatments.
Csizinszky et al. (1995) conducted a field research in three
seasons to find out the effect of plastic mulch having six colors
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 25
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
on yield and insect pest incidence in tomatoes. It was found that
extra-large and marketable fruit yields were higher at blue
mulch, whereas early marketable yields were higher at red mulch.
Asiegbu (1991) compared performance of four mulching materials
(viz. Black p1astic, cassava peel, giant star grass and guinea
grass straw) and found that black plastic mulch was most
effective in weed control and resulted in more crop growth and
higher fruit yield of tomato and eggplant.
Vegetative cover crops, particularly hairy vetch, have been shown
to be a profitable management practice for fresh-market tomato
production resulting in higher tomato yields and lower production
costs than polyethylene mulch or bare soil (Kelly et al. 1995).
Gross returns from tomatoes grown in hairy vetch residues were
also higher than from the polyethylene mulch. The combination of
environmental benefits and the economic benefits to the grower
make the hairy vetch mulch system an attractive alternative for
producing fresh-market tomatoes in the Mid-Atlantic and parts of
northeastern United States (Kelly et al. 1995). Abdul-Baki et al.
(1996b) found higher yields and heavier fruit in hairy vetch than
in bare soil or black polyethylene mulch. Abdul-Baki et al. (1997)
also found that tomato yields were higher for the hairy vetch
than for the black polyethylene mulch.
Abdul-Baki et al. (2002) conducted a field research in 1996 and
1997 to compare the marketable yield of 12 fresh-market tomato
genotypes when grown under plastic and hairy vetch mulches.
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 26
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Tomatoes were grown in conventional tillage plastic mulch and no-
till hairy vetch mulch. The yield of’ eight of the genotypes was
significantly higher in the hairy vetch mulch than in the plastic
mulch system in both the years, ranging from 12% to 57% higher in
1996 and 10% to 48% higher in 1997.
But in a similar study, Creamer et al. (19%) found that tomato
yield was lower with a cover crop mixture containing hairy vetch
as the dominant component than without a cover crop. Similarly,
Yaffa et al. (2000) also found that hairy vetch as a cover crop
increased soil inorganic nitrogen, but it did not increased
tomato yield. Further studies are needed to evaluate the effects
of a hairy vetch cover crop on fresh market tomato, because hairy
vetch has been known to substantially increase tomato yield
(Abdul-Baki and Teasdale, 1993; Kelly et al., 1995; Abdul-Baki et al.,
1996a).
An experiment was carried out by Ann and Ankara (2001) to
determine the effect of low-tunnel, mulch and pruning treatments
on yield and earliness of tomato in unheated glasshouse. Among
the mulch applications, the wheat straw gave the highest yield
while the control gave the lowest. The average fruit weight was
also significantly higher in the crops grown under straw mulch.
A general increase in plant growth and fruit size in hot peppers
was observed by the use of plastic mulch while clear plastic
mulch increased the early and total yield by 39% and 19%
respectively (Pakyurel et al., 1993).
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 27
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Brown et al. (2001) reported that bell peppers grown on black
plastic mulch alone or in combination with drip irrigation
increased pepper yields by 18 and 16 metric tons ha-1
respectively when compared with bare soil.
2.8 Effects of mulch colors on plant growth and development
The change in vegetable crop yield in response to the different
mulch colors is due in part to an increase in soil temperature
and the range of reflected wavelengths produced by individual
mulch colors (Orzolek and Otjen, 2003). Natural soils and plant
residues (including mulches) are of many colors, and they can
reflect a wide range of photosynthetic and morphogenic light to
influence yield and quality of growing plants. Photosynthetically
active light is a well-known component of the growth environment,
contributing to more than 90% of the dry matter through
photosynthetic process (Kasperbauer, 1992). The most influential
colors of morphogenic light appear to be far- red (FR), red (R),
and blue (BL) (Antonious and Kasperbauer, 2002).
The ratio of far-red to red light is important in phytochrorne
regulation of plant physiological process (Borthwick, 1972) and
is a dominant factor in distribution and use (partitioning) of
photosynthate within developing plants (Kasperbauer and Hunt,
1992).
On the basis of earlier controlled environment experiments
(Kasperbauer, 1971), it was predicted that a FR/R photon ratio
higher than the ratio in incoming sunlight (at the same time and
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 28
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
place) would favor shoot crops, and a FR/R ratio lower than the
ratio in incoming light would favor below ground crops.
Kasperbauer (1992) also concluded that the mulch surface colors
that reflected FR/R ratio higher than the ratio in incoming
sunlight resulted in plants that allocated more photo assimilate
to shoots, including fruit.
Different mulch colors reflect different wavelengths and thus
different FR/R ratios (Orzolek and Otjen, 2003). Red plastic
mulch reflected a FR/R photon ratio that was higher than the
ratio in incoming sunlight at the same time and place
(Kasperbauer, 1999). It favored above-ground growth, including
fruit yield of high value crops such as tomato (Kasperbauer and
Hunt, 1998) and strawberry (Kasperbauer, 2000). In addition to
the higher yield of these two crops, the color of light reflected
to the fruit during its development also influenced concentration
of some flavor and nutrient components in the ripe fruit
(Kasperbauer et al. 2001). Light reflected from red mulch had a
higher FR/R ratio than normal sunlight (Matheny et al. 1992) and
the higher FR/R ratio helped enhance the carbohydrate movement
into the developing tomato fruit resulting in increased early
production (Kasperbauer and Hunt, 1998). Similarly, soybean
seedlings developed longer stems over green and red mulches which
reflected higher FR/R ratio than were present in incoming
sunlight whereas the largest roots and lowest shoot/root biomass
ratio for root crop (radish) developed over orange mulch, which
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 29
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
reflected a FR/R ratio lower than the ratio in incoming sunlight
(Kasperbauer, 1992).
The influence of color of Polyethylene mulch on tomato production
was investigated by Decoteau et al. (1989). Tomato plants grown
with red mulch generally had the greatest early marketable yields
and produce the least amount of foliage. Plants grown with a
white or sliver colored mulch had lower early marketable yields
but produce more foliage. These results suggest that mulch
surface color can induce changes in the plant microclimate (e.g.
spectral balance and quantity of light, root zone temperatures)
that can act through natural regulatory system within the growing
plant and affect through natural regulatory system within the
growing plant and affect tomato plant and fruit production.
Chaudhary et al. (2002) conducted an experiment at National
Agriculture Research Centre, Islamabad, Pakistan to investigate
the effect of different colored (black, red and green) plastic
mulches on nutrient contents, growth and yield of tomato. They
found the effect of different colored plastic mulch on the tomato
yield was significant. The highest value was recorded with green
plastic mulch, followed by red and black plastic mulch. The
lowest value was recorded in the control. The green plastic
mulch, red plastic mulch and black plastic mulches produced 154,
101 and 40% yield increase over control.
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 30
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Masiunas et al. (2003) also found the effect of mulch color on
total yield of tomato. They obtained highest tomato yield in the
blue color foam mulch.
2.9 Effects on fruit quality
In addition to the higher yield of the crop, the color of the
mulch also influences the chemical composition of plant products.
Bin-Abdullah (1990) found quality of marketable tomato was better
under polyethylene mulch compared with unmulched Control.
Antonious and Kasperbauer (2002) found that carrot roots from
yellow and white plastic covered plots had higher concentration
of fl-carotene and ascorbic acid and yellow and black covered
plots had higher concentration of pheriolics. Abdul-Baki et al.
(1996b) found highest soluble solid in tomatoes with black
polyethylene and lowest was had the greatest early marketable
yields and produced the least amount of foliage. Plants grown
with white or silver-colored mulch had lower early marketable
yields but produced more foliage. These results suggest that
mulch surface color can induce changes in the plant microclimate
(e.g., spectral balance and quantity of light, root zone
temperatures) that can act through natural regulatory systems
within the growing plant and affect tomato plant growth and fruit
production.
Kasperbauer and Hunt (1998) concluded that increased tomato yield
over the red plastic mulch was caused by reflection of FR to the
growing plants and its subsequent phytochrome-mediated regulation
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 31
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
of photosynthate allocation to developing fruit. Number, size,
and total fruit produced over the red plastic mulches were
compared with those over standard black plastic. Because soil
temperature affects production of horticultural crops (Bhella,
1988b), that component was minimized in a tomato productivity
study done by Kasperbauer and Hunt (1998). They used a layer of
red plastic over the standard black plastic which resulted in a
very similar soil temperature but quite different reflection
spectra in both the treatments (black plastic and red over the
black). This experimental system allowed evaluation of yield
response to reflected spectrum while minimizing soil temperature
effects.
Photodegradable red mulch (placed over a layer of black plastic)
increased fruit yield while it was intact, but yield dropped to
that of the black control after the red plastic degraded. Non-
degradable red plastic resulted in greater yield. Early crop
yield advantage of red mulch was evident whether it was placed
directly over soil or over a layer of black plastic (Kasperbauer
and Hunt, 1998). Similarly Kaul and Kasperbauer (1992)
investigated the effect of various plastic mulch colors (viz.
white, blue red and black) on fruit yield of peppers (Capsicum
annum L.). Data were collected on rhizosphere (soil) temperature,
spectral balance of reflected light, and fruit yield. Fruit
yields were highest over red mulch even though soil temperature
did not differ under red, black and blue mulches. However, plants
grown over red mulch received more reflected far-red light and
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 32
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
higher FR/R light ratio. These findings clearly showed that yield
response of tomato as well as pepper over the red mulch was also
due to the reflection not only due to the increase in soil
temperature.
2.10 Effects on insect pest population
Mulches have been found to be useful for the control of insects.
Use of reflective silver and white plastic mulches to delay onset
of aphid vectored viruses in summer squash has been well
documented in the research literature (Conway et al. 1989; Lamont
et al. 1990). As yellow color is known to attract insects, yellow
color plastic can be used to control insect with insecticide
spray over the mulch (Lamont, 1991).
Scott et al. (1989) investigated the effect of the type of mulch
used (black plastic, aluminum-painted plastic or no mulch) on
aerial thrips population in staked tomato and found that
aluminum-painted mulch was most effective in reducing the numbers
of thrips while black plastic was more effective than no mulch.
Schalk and Robbins (1987) found that aphids (Nezara viridula) were
repelled by the aluminum mulches, while fruit injury was found to
have increased due to attack by tomato pinworm (Kesferia lycopersicella)
and tomato fruit worm (Heliothis zea) which appeared to have been
attracted to the reflective surfaces.
Highly reflective mulches drive insects away, though the
mechanism isn’t fully understood. It’s believed that reflecting
UV wavelengths makes plants invisible to pests like thrips,
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 33
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
aphids, or white fly, so they don’t land on the plants and spread
mosaic virus (Schut, 2001).
Field studies were conducted by Csizinszky et al. (1995) for three
seasons on the effect of six mulch colors: blue, orange, red,
aluminum, yellow, and white (fall) or black (spring), on fruit
yields and on insect vectors of Sunny tomato. Aphids, thrips and
whiteflies were counted monthly in traps placed on the mulched
beds. Aphids were least numerous on the aluminum and yellow mulch
and most numerous on the blue mulch. The fewest thrips were
captured on aluminum and the fewest whiteflies were captured on
the yellows aluminum and orange mulches. Low numbers of
whiteflies on the orange and aluminum mulches delayed virus
symptom development and increased yields.
Csizinszky et al. (1999) again conducted field studies for three
seasons on the effect of ultraviolet (UV)-reflective films
(mulches) on the silver leaf whitefly and on the yield of staked,
fresh-market tomatoes. Whitefly populations in the fall season
were lower on the aluminum than on the silver mulches. In the
spring whiteflies were more numerous on the black control and
silver on white, than on aluminum mulches.
Farias-Larios and Orzoc-Santos (1997) concluded that clear
plastic mulch could be a practical management tool for reducing
insect populations, virus incidence and increasing soil
temperature, watermelon production and enhancement of fruit
quality. Aphids were less severe on clear plastic mulch than on
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 34
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
bare soil and black plastic mulch. Low numbers of whiteflies on
the white and clear plastic mulches during early cycle of culture
delayed virus symptom development.
2.11 Effects on disease incidence and spread
Increase in soil temperature by application of plastic mulch
caused a significant reduction in pathogen levels, at lower cost
than un-mulched, fumigated soi1 fields and at lower phytotoxicity
levels (Abdul-Baki et al., 1996). Clear plastic mulch has repellent
effect on vector; aphids, in Lupinus angustifolius (Jones, 1991),
which has reflective effect and help in reducing the appearance
of viral disease confusing aphids in cantaloupe (Orozco-Santos et
al., 1995).
Mulch also helps reduce the disease incidence. Mulch application
increased microbial activity and biomass in soil (Manna et al.
2001) and reduced the severity of some above ground diseases of
plants in crops such as tomatoes (Abbasi et al. 2002).
Hung and Chen (1985) found that the mulched plants of tomato
showed better results on disease and weed control than the un-
mulched plants. Mulching materials help reduce anthracnose, stem
rot, and virus infection. Effect of black plastic mulch on the
incidence of southern blight disease in bell pepper was
investigated by Brown et al. (1989). They found that disease
incidence and severity were lower and yields were higher in plots
with black polythene mulch than in plots with bare soil.
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 35
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV) is the most serious disease
of tomatoes throughout the Mediterranean region, the Middle East
and the tropical regions of the world (Makkouk and Laterrot,
1983). It is very destructive disease transmitted by whitefly,
Bemisia tabaci. TYLCV disease has become a major factor limiting
tomato production and losses range from 28 to 92% (AlMusa, 1982).
Some reports are available regarding effects of mulching on TYLCV
incidence. Mulch type and color influence growth, yield and
whitefly population in tomato (Csizinszky et al. 1995). Cohen and
Melarned-Macljar (1978) also found that soil covered by colored
plastics reduces the incidence of TYLCV in fresh market tomatoes.
Suwwan et al. (1989) studied the effect of different kinds of mulch
on the incidence of tomato yellow leaf curl (TYLC) virus. Five
different types of mulch viz, silver (aluminum treated
reflective) plastic, black plastic, paper, white/black plastic
and black/White plastic were evaluated. The incidence of TYLC
virus was reduced by silver plastic mulch. While incidence of
sunscald increased significantly in silver and white/black
plastic mulches.
Similarly tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) is another serious
viral disease which is spread by 2 thrips genera, Franklinielia and
Thrips. This disease has threatened almost all the tomato growers
of southern US. Farmers of the southern US are applying costly
and highly toxic broad-spectrum insecticides on a calendar basis
to control the insect vector but the researches have shown that
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 36
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
losses to solanaceous crops in the southern US from TSWV
typically is the result of primary infection which cannot be
prevented by insecticide use (Bauske et al. 1998). Momol et al. (2002)
conducted a five years (1996- 2000) research to study combined
effect of a insecticide (spinosad), a systemic acquired
resistance inducer (Actigard) and UV-reflective metalized mulch
on management of tomato spotted wilt virus. The overall incidence
of TSWV was significantly lower in metalized mulch plots than the
black mulch plots. Application of Actigard was effective in
reducing disease incidence on black mulch but not on metalized
mulch. The regiment of metalized mulch, Actigard and insecticides
reduced tomato spotted wilt virus by as much as 76%.
The effect of plastic film mulches on thrips immigration and
tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) incidence in tomato, pepper, and
tobacco fields was studied by Greenough et al. (1990). Three
treatments (aluminum surfaced plastic mulch, black plastic mulch,
arid a non mulched control) were compared. Thrips immigration
into treatments plots was estimated with the use of yellow sticky
board traps. Compared with the non mulched treatment, aluminum-
surfaced mulch reduced the numbers of trapped thrips by 68% and
the incidence of TSWV by 64% in tomato (Greenough et al., 1990).
Southern blight, caused by soil borne fungus Sclerotium rolfsii,
affects more than 500 plant species in over 100 plant families,
which is a severe problem in many parts of the world and
particularly deleterious to processing tomato (Bulluck and
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 37
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
Ristaino, 2002). Control of southern blight has been achieved
primarily through soil fumigation and fungicide use (Munnecke et
al. 1982.; Punja et al. 1986); however, chemical control can be
expensive and is not completely effective because of the clumped
distribution of inoculum and resilient nature of sclerotia
(Bulluck and Ristaino, 2002). Cultural control methods have been
used to manage southern blight, including application of mulches
and soil solarization (Brown et al., 1989; Ristaino et al., 1991).
Mulches (clear or colored plastic, straw, or nylon) limit disease
incidence by creating a physical barrier that prevents inoculum
contact with the above ground portion of the plant (Brown et al.,
1989). Solarization with clear plastic mulch has also been used
to reduce sclerotia survival at shallow soil depths (Ristaino et
al., 1 991). Tu et al. (1991) studied the effectiveness of clear
plastic mulch for the control of southern blight disease of
tomato and found that the mulching treatment was effective in
controlling the disease. The sclerotia of S. rolfsii could not
survive in the soil surface and under soil surface 5 cm in depth.
However, the Planting row amended with green manure and mulched
with plastic sheet was better for the disease control than the
mulching treatment alone. Similarly Brown et al. (1989) found black
polyethylene mulch effectively suppress the incidence of southern
blight in pepper.
Elmer and Ferrandino (1991) compared paper mulch and black
plastic mulch with no mulch on tomatoes for incidence of blossom
end rot. Black plastic mulch significantly increased early season
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 38
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
blossom end rot relative to paper or no mulch. While late season
blossom end rot was decreased with paper or black plastic mulch
relative to no mulch. However Suwwan et al. (1989) found blossom
end rot incidence was not affected by mulch treatments.
2.12 Effects on nematode infestation
Root-knot nematodes are common root parasites associated with
vegetable and field crops in temperate and tropical regions of
the world (Sasser and Carter, 1982). Root-knot nematodes
(Meloidogyne spp.) are one of the variety of root-parasitic
nematodes that establish specialized feeding cells in roots,
redirecting photosynthate produced in the leaves to supply the
energy demands of the nematode in the roots (Dufour et al., 2003)
as a result of which root biomass increases (Fortnum et al., 1991).
Colored mulches, which vary in quantity and spectral balance of
reflected light, have been shown to alter root-knot nematode
development in tomato. Plants grown over white mulch had greater
numbers of M. incognita eggs per gram dry root weight than similar
plant grown over red or black mulch. Mulch color did not alter
root mass in uninoculated plants. However, root mass in plant
grown over white mulch and inoculated with M. incognita increased
with increasing nematode population, whereas root mass of plants
grown over black or red mulch plateaued at higher nematode
populations (Fortnum et al., 1995).
The effects of different-colored polyethylene mulches on the
quantity and spectra of reflected light, earliness of fruit set,
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 39
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
fruit yield and quality and root-knot disease were studied in
field-grown, staked tomato by Fortnum el al. (1997). Fruit yields
were recorded for tomato plants inoculated with Meloidogyne incognita
at initial populations of 0, 1,000, 10,000, 50,000, or 100,000
eggs/plant and grown over black, white, or red plastic mulch.
Plants grown over red mulch in the spring and inoculated with
50,000 eggs of M. incognita had greater early marketable yields
than similarly inoculated plants grown over black or white mulch.
Investigations at the Agricultural Research Service in Florence,
South Carolina indicated that red plastic mulch suppresses root-
knot nematode damage in tomatoes. The red mulch reflects
wavelengths of light that cause the plant to keep more growth
above ground, which results in greater yield. Meanwhile, the
plant is putting less energy into its root system, the very food,
the nematodes feed on. So reflection from the red mulch, in
effect, tugs food away from the nematodes that are trying to draw
nutrients from the roots. The research team planted tomatoes in
sterilized soil, mulched them with red or black plastic, and
inoculated the roots with nematodes. Plants that were inoculated
with 200,000 nematode eggs and mulched with black plastic
produced 8 pounds of tomatoes, while those mulched with red
plastic produced 17 pounds (Dufour et al., 2003).
3. Conclusion
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 40
Effect of plastic mulch in vegetables production. 2011
A favorable soil-water-plant relation is created by placing mulch
over the soil surface. The microclimate surrounding the plant and
soil is significantly affected by mulch i.e. the thermodynamic
environment, the moisture, the erosion, the physical soil
structure, the incidence of pests and diseases, crop growth and
yield. In order to maximize water and nutrient use efficiency by
the plant and to improve the quality of produce, the use of mulch
has become an important cultural practice in many regions of the
world for the commercial production of vegetable crops.
References
Prepared by: Amit Khanal, M.Sc. (Horticulture)Page 41